Waranch and Brown’s Christina N. Billiet and Rachel E. Giroux recently secured a defense verdict in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City. This sensitive case involved a young mother, struggling with opioid addiction, who delivered a premature baby and later developed severe complications of infection, including amputations and lifelong dialysis. In today’s video, Tina and Rachel share some of the strategies which led to their success in this complex trial.
Watch the Video Think Piece on W&B TV »
A key factor in this victory was the strategic use of contributory negligence. We presented the evidence in a way that was both respectful and compelling, and it resonated soundly with the jury. Post-verdict discussions confirmed that this approach significantly influenced their decision.
We also faced and effectively countered attempts by plaintiff’s counsel to utilize Golden Rule and reptilian arguments — tactics designed to appeal to the jury’s emotions. By addressing this proactively with the judge and staying alert throughout the trial, we ensured that the jury’s verdict was based on facts rather than emotional appeals.
Finally, this trial reinforced the importance of treater testimony. Despite having strong expert witnesses, it was the testimony from the treating physicians which left the most lasting impression on the jury. Preparing treaters to present as credible and to connect with jurors is often the most important factor in securing a defense verdict.
At Waranch & Brown, we pride ourselves on our ability to defend our clients with precision and tenacity, even in the most challenging legal environments. Whether you are facing a difficult case or seeking legal guidance, our team is here to help.