Medical malpractice verdicts can offer healthcare professionals valuable insight into how juries evaluate issues relating to standard of care, causation and clinical decision-making. At Waranch & Brown, we closely monitor medical malpractice verdicts across Maryland to gain valuable insight into the arguments, evidence, and themes that resonate with today’s juries. Below are several recent defense verdicts illustrating trends we are following in Maryland courts.
Montgomery County (January 2025)
Claim: Physicians failed to identify a newborn baby’s congenital heart defect during her newborn examination and such failure caused her death at eight days of life.
Result: Defense verdict in favor of physician. Although the baby’s cause of death was unexplained, and tragic, it was not due to a breach in the standard of care.
Baltimore County (July 2025)
Claim: Physician performed a kyphoplasty on the wrong vertebra.
Result: Defense verdict. The jury found a breach of the standard of care but concluded that the plaintiff failed to prove causation because the vertebra was treated before any significant injury or lasting sequelae developed.
Baltimore City (August 2025)
Claim: Alleged failure to timely recognize and treat a worsening right upper-thigh infection following liver transplant, resulting in necrotizing infection, above-the-knee amputation, transplant rejection, and death.
Result: Defense verdict obtained on behalf of all healthcare providers. The plaintiff was critically ill, and the evidence showed that her death was unavoidable and not attributable to any healthcare provider.
Baltimore City (December 2025)
Claim: Failure to perform a tracheostomy after a post-operative tongue cancer patient returned to the emergency department with oral bleeding.
Result: Defense verdict for the physician. The jury ultimately sided with the defense’s argument that oral intubation alone met the emergency medicine standard of care.
Howard County (December 2025)
Claim: Allegations that a viable intrauterine pregnancy was erroneously diagnosed as an ectopic pregnancy, resulting in the administration of medication that terminated the pregnancy.
Result: Defense verdict. The jury did not find a breach in the standard of care on behalf of any providers, as there were serious concerns for an ectopic pregnancy.
Prince George’s County (March 2026)
Claim: Delay in diagnosing and treating a popliteal artery injury following a traumatic fall resulting in an above-the-knee amputation.
Result: Verdict in favor of the vascular surgeon, despite allegations of delayed diagnosis. Although the jury found a breach in the standard of care, it concluded that the plaintiff failed to prove causation, crediting medical literature showing that 6 to 8 hours of ischemia most often results in amputation.
Prince George’s County (April 2026)
Claim: Emergency physician failed to administer tPA to a 51-year-old female who presented to the hospital with altered mental status within 3 hours of her last known well time and that the failure to give tPA caused her to suffer a second stroke 1½ years later.
Result: Defense verdict. The defense contended that tPA was not indicated because the patient presented with generalized encephalopathy and no focal neurological deficits.
Anne Arundel County (June 2026)
Claim: Radiologist failed to identify an acute ventricular hemorrhage, leading to the patient’s obstructive hydrocephalus and death.
Result: Defense verdict. The defense successfully argued that the timing of the patient’s deterioration was inconsistent with the presence of an active hemorrhage at the time the CT scan was interpreted.
These results underscore a fundamental reality: every verdict provides an opportunity to learn. Analyzing recent defense wins helps us better anticipate challenges before they arise so we can better defend our clients. If you have questions or concerns about an upcoming medical malpractice matter, the attorneys at Waranch & Brown are available to discuss the issues involved and help you prepare for what may lie ahead.
