Neal Brown

Neal Brown

Who Lost the Right to Attend the Deposition?

A physician defendant appears for deposition with her lawyer. To their surprise, plaintiff’s counsel brought along a “nurse advisor” to the deposition. This advisor was not a party, a party’s lawyer (or the lawyer’s employee) or an expert witness. Does that nurse advisor have a right to be present at the deposition? In the past, this was permissible, but as of April 1, 2017, the answer is “No!”

Pursuant to Rule 2-413.1, absent a court order or agreement, the only people allowed to attend a deposition are:

  • The court reporter;
  • An individual acting under the direction of the court reporter;
  • A party (if that party is an individual);
  • If the party is not an individual, one representative other than the party’s attorney;
  • The parties’ attorneys;
  • A non-attorney member of the attorney’s staff needed to assist in the representation;
  • The witness;
  • An attorney for the witness; and
  • An expert witness expected to testify on the subject matter of the deposition.

So what does this mean?  The “nurse advisor” was not a party, a party’s attorney (or the lawyer’s employee) or expert witness in the case. Moreover, there was no court order or agreement among the parties. Even though the nurse advisor once had a right to attend the deposition, that door is now CLOSED.

Bottom Line: Know who can – and cannot – attend a deposition before you go.  You may be able to prevent a party’s non-expert “advisor” or any other individual not listed above, from attending and interfering with the process.

If we can help with this, or anything else, please contact us.

Neal Brown

Neal Brown

Neal Brown is a Fellow of the American College of Trial Lawyers and a Martindale-Hubbell AV-rated trial attorney. He is a founding partner of Waranch & Brown, where he has devoted his career to defending hospitals and health care providers in medical malpractice and related cases.